Arte SheetsLearn. Try. Understand.

Civil, Structural & Geotechnical Engineering

Bishop Simplified Method: One Illustrative Slice Iteration

Work through one trial-factor update for a three-slice circular slope example and distinguish an iteration from a complete stability assessment.

An implicit calculation for a circular slip surface

The simplified Bishop method is a limit-equilibrium method commonly used for circular slip surfaces. It uses overall moment equilibrium and vertical equilibrium of each slice, with interslice shear neglected. It does not satisfy overall horizontal force equilibrium. The soil parameters, water pressures, loads, candidate surface and analysis assumptions all influence the result.

For the simplified effective-stress expression illustrated here, mᵢ = cos(αᵢ) + sin(αᵢ) tan(φ′)/F_trial. One updated trial factor is Σ[(c′bᵢ + (Wᵢ − uᵢbᵢ)tan(φ′))/mᵢ] / Σ[Wᵢ sin(αᵢ)]. Slice width b is horizontal, W is weight per unit out-of-plane width, u is pore-water pressure at the base, α is base angle, c′ is effective cohesion and φ′ is effective friction angle. This version assumes the same c′ and φ′ for all three slices and no added loads.

For the three illustrative slices below, c′ = 15 kPa, φ′ = 28° and F_trial = 1.40. The update is 1.511842, displayed as 1.512. It is one iteration, not a converged solution. Using the unrounded update as the next trial gives about 1.527737; further iterations of this particular example approach 1.53015.

Illustrative sliceHorizontal width b (m)Weight W (kN/m)Base angle α (degrees)Pore pressure u (kPa)m at trial F = 1.40
1428036121.0323
2439022241.0695
342108151.0431

Trial-factor update in the worksheet

Enter the trial factor in G4. E2:E4 compute the three unrounded m values and G5 computes one unrounded update; G6 displays it to three decimals. To explore iteration, copy the unrounded value from G5 to G4 and repeat, checking the change against a chosen tolerance. Convergence and the number of iterations depend on the case; the worksheet does not search for a critical slip surface or establish that the result has converged.

The input checks deliberately restrict this teaching example to positive widths and weights, base angles from 0° to less than 80°, friction angles from 0° to less than 45°, nonnegative cohesion and pore pressure, and positive trial factor. They reject zero driving sum and cases with nonpositive calculated effective normal force. These checks are exercise restrictions, not a complete set of physical or design-validity criteria.

=IF(COUNT(A2:D4)+COUNT(G2:G4)<>15,"Enter all numeric inputs",IF(OR(MIN(A2:A4)<=0,MIN(B2:B4)<=0,MIN(C2:C4)<0,MAX(C2:C4)>=80,MIN(D2:D4)<0,G2<0,G3<0,G3>=45,G4<=0),"Check example inputs",IF(OR(MIN(E2:E4)<=0,(B2*SIN(RADIANS(C2))+B3*SIN(RADIANS(C3))+B4*SIN(RADIANS(C4)))<=0,B2-D2*A2-G2*A2*TAN(RADIANS(C2))/G4<=0,B3-D3*A3-G2*A3*TAN(RADIANS(C3))/G4<=0,B4-D4*A4-G2*A4*TAN(RADIANS(C4))/G4<=0),"Outside example assumptions",((G2*A2+(B2-D2*A2)*TAN(RADIANS(G3)))/E2+(G2*A3+(B3-D3*A3)*TAN(RADIANS(G3)))/E3+(G2*A4+(B4-D4*A4)*TAN(RADIANS(G3)))/E4)/(B2*SIN(RADIANS(C2))+B3*SIN(RADIANS(C3))+B4*SIN(RADIANS(C4))))))

Limits of this example

The example is not a design calculation or an assessment of an actual slope. Three chosen slices and a single assumed circular surface cannot establish the critical factor of safety. Geometry, geological variability, groundwater, loading, construction and failure mechanisms require a qualified geotechnical assessment.

The US Army Corps of Engineers notes that simplified Bishop does not meet horizontal force equilibrium and recommends checking major structures using a rigorous method such as Spencer’s method. Never infer site safety or a universal percentage error from this worksheet.

Try the example

Use the original values or change them to test your understanding.

Further reading