Arte SheetsLearn. Try. Understand.

Well Control & Drilling Operations, Burkhardt (1961) Pipe-Tripping Surge & Swab Hydraulics

Burkhardt Wellbore Surge & Swab Tripping Pressure Formula

Calculate Burkhardt Effective Annular Fluid Velocity Veff (m/s), Laminar Annular Surge/Swab Pressure Change (kPa), Running-In Surge EMW (SG), and Pulling-Out Swab EMW (SG).

Over-65% of oilfield gas blowouts start NOT while drilling, but when pulling drillpipe too fast swabs bottomhole pressure below pore pressure

Running a plugged/float-valved drillstring (Collar/Pipe OD D_p mm) into an open borehole (Hole ID D_h mm) at Hoist Tripping Speed V_p (m/s) acts like a leaky hydraulic piston. J. A. Burkhardt (1961, SPE-1546) proved that total upward mud shear combines 1) **Closed-End Volumetric Displacement V_p * (D_p^2 / (D_h^2 - D_p^2)) PLUS 2) Viscous Wall-Clinging Drag K * V_p (Clinging Constant K ~= 0.45 for annular D_p / D_h ~ 0.6–0.7), driving Effective Annular Mud Velocity Veff = V_p * ((D_p^2 / (D_h^2 - D_p^2)) + K) (m/s). Across Radial Slot Clearance Hslot = (D_h - D_p) / 2,000 (m), Mud Viscosity mu (mPa·s), and String Length L (m vertical), laminar slot shear generates Delta_Ptrip = ((12 * (mu / 1,000) * Veff) / Hslot^2) * (L / 1,000) (kPa), spiking bottomhole Running-In-Hole Surge EMWsurge = SGmud + Delta_P / (9.80665 * L) (fracture/lost-circulation risk) and dropping Pulling-Out-of-Hole Swab EMWswab = SGmud - Delta_P / (9.80665 * L)** (swabbed gas-kick risk).

Verify on a Controlled 0.45 m/s (~20 s per 9 m single) Trip with 5" (127.0 mm) Pipe in an 8.5" (215.9 mm) Hole—Pipe_OD D_p = 127.0 mm (B2), Hole_ID D_h = 215.9 mm (B3), Burkhardt_Clinging K = 0.45 (B4), Hoist_Trip_Speed V_p = 0.45 m/s (B5), Plastic_Viscosity mu = 28.0 mPa·s (B6), String_TVD L = 2,800 m (B7), and Static_Mud SG = 1.340 (B8): Veff equals 0.441 m/s (E2), Trip Pressure equals a gentle 209.8 kPa (30 psi, E3), keeping Surge EMW at 1.348 SG (E4) and Swab EMW safely overbalanced at 1.332 SG (E5).

Burkhardt Surge/Swab KPI (Dp=127 mm, K=0.45, TVD=2,800 m, Static Mud=1.340 SG)FormulaVerified Output
Effective Fluid Velocity Veff (m/s)Vp * ((Dp^2 / (Dh^2 - Dp^2)) + Cling_K)0.441 m/s (2.247 m/s fast pull in slim hole)
Surge / Swab Friction dP (kPa)((12 * (mu/1000) * Veff) / ((Dh-Dp)/2000)^2)*L/1000209.8 kPa (5,489.5 kPa = 796 psi swab)
Running-In Surge EMW (SG)Static_SG + Trip_dP_kPa / (9.80665 * TVD_m)1.348 SG (1.540 SG lost-returns fracture)
Pulling-Out Swab EMW (SG)Static_SG - Trip_dP_kPa / (9.80665 * TVD_m)1.332 SG (1.140 SG SWABBED GAS KICK)

Burkhardt (1961) Closed-End Piston Displacement + Clinging Drag Formula

Validate Pipe_OD >= 50 mm, Hole_ID >= Pipe_OD + 25 mm, Clinging_Factor K in [0.30, 0.55], Trip_Speed V_p in (0, 3.0] m/s, Viscosity mu in [1, 150] mPa·s, TVD >= 100 m, and Static_Mud_SG in [0.85, 2.50].

=LET(dp_m, B2, dh_m, B3, kc_f, B4, vp_s, B5, mu_c, B6, lv_m, B7, sg_m, B8, ve_s, vp_s * (((dp_m ^ 2) / ((dh_m ^ 2) - (dp_m ^ 2))) + kc_f), hs_m, (dh_m - dp_m) / 2000, pt_k, ((12 * (mu_c / 1000) * ve_s) / (hs_m ^ 2)) * (lv_m / 1000), IF(OR(dp_m < 50, dh_m < dp_m + 25, kc_f < 0.3, kc_f > 0.55, vp_s <= 0, vp_s > 3, mu_c < 1, mu_c > 150, lv_m < 100, sg_m < 0.85, sg_m > 2.5), "Invalid Trip Input", ROUND(sg_m - (pt_k / (9.80665 * lv_m)), 3)))

Fast Hoisting Across Tight BHA/Slim Hole (D_h = 171.5 mm, V_p = 1.35 m/s, mu = 36 cP) Swab-Kick Check

Yank 5" collars out of a 6.75" (B3 = 171.5 mm) slim hole or balled-up stabilizer at B5 = 1.35 m/s in 36 cP mud (B6 = 36): Veff E2 surges 5.1x to 2.247 m/s, Swab Suction E3 spikes 26x to 5,489.5 kPa, and Bottomhole Swab EMW E5 plunges -0.200 SG down to 1.140 SG—sucking formation gas straight into the stairwell.

=IF(ISTEXT(E5), E5, LET(ve_s, B5 * (((B2 ^ 2) / ((B3 ^ 2) - (B2 ^ 2))) + B4), hs_m, (B3 - B2) / 2000, ROUND(((12 * (B6 / 1000) * ve_s) / (hs_m ^ 2)) * (B7 / 1000), 1)))

Try the example

Use the original values or change them to test your understanding.

Further reading