Statistical & Clinical Analysis
England–Fraser and Shine–Lal Indices: Formulas and Limits
Calculate two historical red-cell discriminants with correct units and learn why their numerical values do not diagnose the cause of anemia.
What these indices can and cannot show
England and Fraser published a routine blood-count discriminant in 1973. Shine and Lal later evaluated an index as one component of a 1977 hemoglobinopathy screening strategy in Kentucky. These indices have been studied to help distinguish patterns associated with iron deficiency and beta-thalassemia trait, especially among people with microcytic red cells.
The traditional cutoffs commonly cited are zero for England–Fraser and 1,530 for Shine–Lal. Performance and appropriate interpretation vary by population, laboratory and clinical setting. The original Shine–Lal report stated that no method detected every carrier; a later study found substantially different performance in another population. Neither index can confirm or exclude a condition, and iron deficiency and thalassemia trait can coexist.
A clinical assessment may include iron studies and hemoglobin analysis where appropriate. Do not use the example results as diagnoses or as a substitute for individualized assessment. The spreadsheet exercise has not been clinically validated.
England–Fraser discriminant
Use mean corpuscular volume (MCV) in fL in B2, red blood cell count in millions/µL (equivalently 10¹²/L) in B3, and hemoglobin in g/dL in B4. This version subtracts 3.4, consistent with the cited literature. COUNT requires the three measurements used in this formula.
=IF(COUNT(B2:B4)<>3,"Enter numeric MCV, RBC and hemoglobin",IF(OR(B2<=0,B3<=0,B4<=0),"Check input values",ROUND(B2-B3-5*B4-3.4,2)))Shine–Lal index
Use MCV in fL in B2 and mean corpuscular hemoglobin (MCH) in pg in B5. The index is MCV squared times MCH divided by 100; it does not require the RBC or hemoglobin inputs used by the other formula. Example MCH values are consistent with hemoglobin and RBC count using MCH = 10 × hemoglobin/RBC in these units.
=IF(COUNT(B2,B5)<>2,"Enter numeric MCV and MCH",IF(OR(B2<=0,B5<=0),"Check input values",ROUND((B2^2*B5)/100,1)))Try the example
Use the original values or change them to test your understanding.