Arte SheetsLearn. Try. Understand.

Operations, Logistics & Engineering

Ordinary Method of Slices: An Illustrative Circular-Slip Calculation

Explore the USACE ordinary-method expression for a three-slice example and understand why a worksheet result alone does not establish slope safety.

One assumed surface, one simplified method

The ordinary method of slices, also called the Fellenius method, divides a potential circular slip mass into vertical slices. It neglects the forces on slice sides and uses overall moment equilibrium to calculate a factor for the assumed surface. That result is not the factor for every possible surface and does not by itself establish the condition of a real slope.

This lesson uses the effective-stress expression in USACE EM 1110-2-1902, Equation C-12: F = Σ[c′ℓᵢ + (Wᵢ cos αᵢ − uᵢℓᵢ cos² αᵢ) tan φ′] / Σ[Wᵢ sin αᵢ]. Here W is slice weight per unit out-of-plane width, α is the base angle, ℓ is the approximate base length, u is pore-water pressure at the base, and c′ and φ′ are effective-strength parameters. The example uses the same c′ and φ′ for all slices, with no additional applied loads.

The cos² α term reflects the water-pressure treatment in this particular USACE formulation. Other presentations use a different expression, such as W cos α − uℓ, under different assumptions. Do not interchange the two without checking the force and pore-pressure model.

Example sliceWeight W (kN/m)Base angle α (degrees)Base length ℓ (m)Base pore pressure u (kPa)Normal term in USACE expression (kN/m)
1180422.715111.399
2240242.222178.858
313082.01893.432

Calculate the illustrative ratio

With c′ = 12 kPa and φ′ = 28°, the sum of driving terms is approximately 236.153 kN/m and the unrounded model result is approximately 1.214516, displayed as 1.215. Changing these hypothetical strength parameters to c′ = 24 kPa and φ′ = 33° gives approximately 1.756366. Neither result is a site assessment.

The worksheet requires all inputs, positive slice weights and lengths, nonnegative pore pressures and cohesion, and a positive driving sum. For this exercise, it restricts base angles to 0°–less than 80° and friction angle to 0°–less than 45°, and returns a message if any computed normal term is nonpositive. These are worksheet restrictions, not a comprehensive engineering validity check.

=IF(COUNT(A2:D4)+COUNT(I2:I3)<>14,"Enter all numeric inputs",IF(OR(MIN(A2:A4)<=0,MIN(B2:B4)<0,MAX(B2:B4)>=80,MIN(C2:C4)<=0,MIN(D2:D4)<0,I2<0,I3<0,I3>=45),"Check example inputs",IF(OR(MIN(E2:E4)<=0,SUM(F2:F4)<=0),"Outside example assumptions",(I2*SUM(C2:C4)+TAN(RADIANS(I3))*SUM(E2:E4))/SUM(F2:F4))))

Interpretation requires the full engineering context

Do not infer that a slope is safe, unstable, or requires a specific repair from this example. An appropriate factor depends on loading, material and groundwater uncertainty, consequences, structure type, applicable regulations and the assessment method. USACE gives different minimum values for different conditions for new embankment dams; those numbers are not a universal pass/fail rule for all slopes.

A qualified geotechnical assessment considers geometry, ground conditions, multiple potential slip surfaces, loading, water, appropriate methods and independent checks. The ordinary method can differ substantially from more rigorous methods, particularly in some high-pore-pressure cases.

Try the example

Use the original values or change them to test your understanding.

Further reading