Statistical & Clinical Analysis
Simplified Fencl–Stewart Base Excess: Components and Limits
Calculate the sodium–chloride and albumin effects in the simplified Story model and explore the remaining base-excess residual without treating it as a diagnosis.
What the simplified equations estimate
Story, Morimatsu and Bellomo described simplified equations in 2004 and compared them with more detailed Fencl–Stewart calculations using 300 blood samples from critically ill patients. One estimates the combined sodium–chloride effect as sodium minus chloride minus 38; another estimates the albumin effect as 0.25 times the difference between 42 and albumin in g/L. The constants are reference assumptions within this model.
The model residual is measured standard base excess minus the two estimated effects. The original paper describes it as an estimated effect of unmeasured ions; it is not a direct measurement that isolates or identifies lactate, ketones or any one substance. Other ions, weak acids, approximation and measurement differences may affect the residual. A zero residual does not prove that other influences are absent.
Use sodium, chloride and standard base excess in mEq/L (numerically equivalent to mmol/L for these quantities), and albumin in g/L; multiply albumin in g/dL by 10 first. Interpretation also requires pH, carbon dioxide and the clinical context. A hypothetical panel alone cannot establish a cause such as saline infusion. These calculations are educational examples, not a clinically validated decision tool.
Sodium–chloride contribution
Enter sodium in B2 and chloride in B3. Both must be numeric and positive. This combined estimate does not separately identify a free-water effect and a chloride effect.
=IF(COUNT(B2:B3)<>2,"Enter numeric sodium and chloride",IF(OR(B2<=0,B3<=0),"Check sodium and chloride",ROUND(B2-B3-38,2)))Albumin contribution
Enter albumin in g/L in B4. This calculation only requires the albumin input.
=IF(COUNT(B4)<>1,"Enter numeric albumin",IF(B4<0,"Check albumin",ROUND(0.25*(42-B4),2)))Residual after these two estimated contributions
Enter measured standard base excess in B5, in addition to the first three values. The formula subtracts the two unrounded estimates before rounding the result.
=IF(COUNT(B2:B5)<>4,"Enter all four numeric inputs",IF(OR(B2<=0,B3<=0,B4<0),"Check chemistry inputs",ROUND(B5-(B2-B3-38)-0.25*(42-B4),2)))Try the example
Use the original values or change them to test your understanding.