Clinical Medicine & Physiology
Harris–Benedict and Roza–Shizgal Energy Equations
Compare the original and revised resting-energy equations and understand their study populations and limits.
Two published energy estimates
Harris and Benedict derived sex-specific basal energy equations from measurements in 239 adults. In 1984 Roza and Shizgal recalculated the relationships using those original data plus 98 additional historical subjects, for 337 total: 168 men and 169 women. The extra 168 were not a modern sample; 168 is the number of men in the combined group.
Both equations are estimates in kcal/day, not a direct measurement of a particular person’s metabolism or a complete daily energy requirement. Basal and resting energy measurements use different conditions. Results can differ from measured values, especially in populations unlike the study sample; they are not a diet prescription.
| Version | M equation: W kg, H cm, A years | F equation: W kg, H cm, A years |
|---|---|---|
| Original | 66.473 + 13.7516 W + 5.0033 H − 6.755 A | 655.0955 + 9.5634 W + 1.8496 H − 4.6756 A |
| 1984 revision | 88.362 + 13.397 W + 4.799 H − 5.677 A | 447.593 + 9.247 W + 3.098 H − 4.330 A |
1984 Roza–Shizgal estimate
Enter the M/F coefficient category in B2, weight in kg in B3, height in cm in B4, and adult age in years in B5. In this exercise the basic input checks accept weights 25–300 kg, heights 100–250 cm and ages 18–120. These are worksheet guardrails, not proof that the equations are accurate or validated for everyone in those ranges.
=IF(COUNT(B3:B5)<>3,"Enter M or F and valid adult weight, height, and age",IF(OR(AND(UPPER(TRIM(B2&""))<>"M",UPPER(TRIM(B2&""))<>"F"),B3<25,B3>300,B4<100,B4>250,B5<18,B5>120),"Enter M or F and valid adult weight, height, and age",ROUND(IF(UPPER(TRIM(B2&""))="M",88.362+13.397*B3+4.799*B4-5.677*B5,447.593+9.247*B3+3.098*B4-4.33*B5),1)))Original Harris–Benedict estimate
Use the same entries to compare the older equation. Selecting a coefficient category reproduces the published model; the worksheet does not infer the right category for an individual.
=IF(COUNT(B3:B5)<>3,"Enter M or F and valid adult weight, height, and age",IF(OR(AND(UPPER(TRIM(B2&""))<>"M",UPPER(TRIM(B2&""))<>"F"),B3<25,B3>300,B4<100,B4>250,B5<18,B5>120),"Enter M or F and valid adult weight, height, and age",ROUND(IF(UPPER(TRIM(B2&""))="M",66.473+13.7516*B3+5.0033*B4-6.755*B5,655.0955+9.5634*B3+1.8496*B4-4.6756*B5),1)))Interpret the estimates carefully
Neither figure includes an individually measured activity expenditure. An assumed activity multiplier would be a separate scenario and cannot guarantee a person’s calorie needs. Professional assessment and, where appropriate, measurement are needed for individual clinical decisions.
Try the example
Use the original values or change them to test your understanding.