Synchronous Generator Protection & Commissioning, IEEE C37.102 / ANSI 25 Synchrocheck
IEEE C37.102 Generator Synchrocheck Out-of-Phase Shock
Calculate Phasor Difference Voltage Across Open Breaker dV (pu), Subtransient Synchronizing Surge Current (pu), Synchroscope Beat Period (s), and +/-10-deg Window Dwell Time (s).
Rolled VT secondary leads that close a generator breaker 120° out of phase drive 1.75 pu vector voltage and 7.29x rated current—shearing turbine-generator coupling bolts worse than a 3-phase terminal short
Before closing a generator breaker onto an infinite utility grid, ANSI Device 25 Synchrocheck Relays (IEEE C37.102 / IEEE C50.13) verify Delta_V <= 0.05 pu, Slip Frequency Delta_f = |f_G - f_S| <= 0.067 Hz, and Phase Angle |delta| <= 10°. Across Generator Voltage V_G (pu), Bus Voltage V_S (pu), and Instantaneous Phase Angle delta (deg), the law of cosines fixes **Open-Pole Phasor Difference Voltage Delta_Vvec = sqrt(V_G^2 + V_S^2 - 2 * V_G * V_S * cos(delta)) (pu), which drives Initial Subtransient Stator Shock Current Isync = Delta_Vvec / Xtot'' (pu across X_d'' + XGSU + Xsys). Meanwhile, Slip Frequency Delta_f (Hz) sets Synchroscope 360° Beat Period Tbeat = 1 / Delta_f (s) and +/-10° (20° total) Permissive Dwell Window twin = (20 / 360) / Delta_f** (s)—if twin is shorter than breaker close-coil time (~50–83 ms), an un-compensated manual close misses 0° dead-center.
Build this Commissioning Relay Setting Sheet in a shared cloud workbook—Generator_V_G = 1.02 pu (B2), Grid_Bus_V_S = 1.00 pu (B3), Closing_Angle delta = 8.0° (B4), Total_Loop_Subtransient_Reactance Xtot'' = 0.24 pu (B5), and Slip_Frequency Delta_f = 0.060 Hz (B6): Phasor Difference Delta_Vvec equals 0.1423 pu (E2), Initial Synchronizing Surge Current stays gentle at 0.59 pu (<= 3.0 pu IEEE C50.13 fatigue limit. E3), Beat Period equals 16.67 s (E4), and +/-10° Window Dwell equals 0.926 s (E5). When protection engineers review commissioning workbooks via suggester proposals or the scoped OAuth Arte Sheets ChatGPT 0.1.0 connector (currently In review / Not published; read_range inspects <= 200 raw cells/formulas without recalculating and consumes 0 Arte AI credits under the 120/min account limiter, while apply_changes requires Pro + editor/owner + matching revision and routes concurrent edits to pendingReview), always verify live recalculated Isync inside Arte Sheets before approving relay settings.
| IEEE C37.102 / Device 25 Synchrocheck KPI (VG=1.02 pu, VS=1.00 pu, X''tot=0.24 pu) | Formula | Verified Output |
|---|---|---|
| Vector Voltage Across Breaker (pu) | SQRT(VG^2 + VS^2 - 2*VG*VS*COS(delta_rad)) | 0.1423 pu @ 8° (1.7494 pu @ 120° VT roll) |
| Subtransient Shock Current (pu) | Vector_Diff_dV_pu / Total_Subtrans_X_pu | 0.59 pu SAFE (7.29 pu SHAFT TWIST) |
| Synchroscope 360° Beat Period (s) | 1 / Slip_Frequency_df_Hz | 16.67 s/rev (2.86 s/rev racing governor) |
| +/-10° Permissive Window Time (s) | (20 / 360) / Slip_Frequency_df_Hz | 0.926 s ample (0.159 s late-close risk) |
IEEE C37.102 Law-of-Cosines Synchronizing Shock & Slip-Window Formula
Validate V_G, V_S in [0.80, 1.20] pu, Closing_Angle delta in [0, 180]°, Total X'' in [0.08, 1.50] pu, and Slip_Frequency Delta_f in [0.005, 2.00] Hz.
=LET(vg_p, B2, vs_p, B3, dg_d, B4, xd_p, B5, sf_h, B6, IF(OR(vg_p < 0.8, vg_p > 1.2, vs_p < 0.8, vs_p > 1.2, dg_d < 0, dg_d > 180, xd_p < 0.08, xd_p > 1.5, sf_h < 0.005, sf_h > 2), "Invalid Sync Input", ROUND((20 / 360) / sf_h, 3)))Rolled VT Phase (delta = 120°) + Fast 0.35 Hz Slip Catastrophic Mis-Synchronization Check
Swap A-B-C potential-transformer phase wires during commissioning (delta = B4 = 120°) with fast governor slip (B6 = 0.35 Hz): Permissive Window E5 shrinks to 0.159 s, Open-Breaker Vector Voltage E2 jumps 12x to 1.7494 pu, and Stator Shock Current E3 explodes to 7.29 pu—exceeding GSU winding hoop bracing and shearing turbine coupling keys.
=IF(ISTEXT(E5), E5, LET(dv_p, SQRT((B2 ^ 2) + (B3 ^ 2) - 2 * B2 * B3 * COS((B4 * PI()) / 180)), ROUND(dv_p / B5, 2)))Try the example
Use the original values or change them to test your understanding.