Power System Relaying & Substation Protection, IEEE C37.110 Transient CT Saturation
IEEE C37.110 CT Knee Voltage & X/R Saturation Formula
Calculate Secondary Symmetrical Fault Current (A), Symmetrical Burden Voltage Vs (V), Transient DC-Offset Excitation Demand Vs*(1 + X/R) (V), and % of Knee Voltage Vk.
A C400 relay CT with only 62 V symmetrical burden voltage still saturates violently at 1,178 V when X/R = 18—causing bus differential false trips
Relay engineers checking Protective Current Transformers (CTs, IEEE C37.110) solely against steady-state **Symmetrical Secondary Voltage Vsym = (Ifault / NCT) * Z_b** (where NCT is Turns Ratio e.g. 240 for 1200:5, and Z_b = RCT + 2 * Rlead + Zrelay Ohm) miss 90% of real-world CT saturation events. An asymmetrical fault near a generator or substation transformer (Primary System Inductance-to-Resistance Ratio X / R = 12–30) injects a uni-directional Decaying DC Offset whose core flux integrates (X / R) times higher than 60-Hz AC flux. By the IEEE C37.110 Saturation-Free Criterion, avoiding core clipping altogether requires **Transient Excitation Voltage Vtr = Vsym * (1 + X / R) <= V_k** (CT Saturation Knee Voltage V)—otherwise core flux hits 368% of V_k within 1–2 cycles, chopping secondary waveforms and starving 50 instantaneous elements or falsely tripping 87B bus differential relays on external through-faults.
Verify on a 1200:5 (N = 240), C400-Class (V_k = 320 V knee) Substation Feeder CT with Short Digital-Relay Leads—Primary_Symmetrical_Fault I_f = 24.0 kA (B2), Turns_Ratio NCT = 240 (B3), Total_Secondary_Loop_Burden Z_b = 0.18 Ohm (B4), Primary_System X / R = 12.0 (B5), and CT_Knee_Point V_k = 320.0 V (B6): Secondary Symmetrical Current equals 100.0 A (20x 5 A nominal. E2), Symmetrical Burden Voltage looks tiny at 18.0 V (E3), Transient DC-Offset Flux Demand jumps 13x to 234.0 V (E4), staying safely linear at 73.1% of V_k (E5).
| IEEE C37.110 CT Saturation KPI (24 kA Fault, 1200:5 N=240, Vk=320 V) | Formula | Verified Output |
|---|---|---|
| Secondary Symmetrical Fault (A) | (Primary_Fault_kA * 1000) / Turns_Ratio_N | 100.0 A RMS (20x 5 A tap) |
| Symmetrical Burden Voltage Vs (V) | Secondary_Fault_A * Loop_Burden_Zb_Ohm | 18.0 V (62.0 V @ long #12 AWG yard run) |
| Transient DC-Offset Demand Vtr (V) | Symmetrical_Vs_V * (1 + Primary_X_Over_R) | 234.0 V (1,178.0 V >> 320 V knee) |
| Knee Flux Utilization (%) | (Transient_Demand_Vtr / CT_Knee_Vk_V) * 100 | 73.1% LINEAR (368.1% DEEP SATURATION) |
IEEE C37.110 (1 + X/R) Transient Dimensioning Factor & Knee-Point Formula
Validate Primary_Fault I_f in [0.5, 100] kA, Turns_Ratio N in [10, 2,000], Loop_Burden Z_b in [0.02, 10.0] Ohm, Primary X/R in [1, 80], and CT_Knee V_k in [20, 2,000] V.
=LET(if_k, B2, nc_t, B3, zb_o, B4, xr_r, B5, vk_v, B6, is_a, (if_k * 1000) / nc_t, vt_r, (is_a * zb_o) * (1 + xr_r), IF(OR(if_k < 0.5, if_k > 100, nc_t < 10, nc_t > 2000, zb_o < 0.02, zb_o > 10, xr_r < 1, xr_r > 80, vk_v < 20, vk_v > 2000), "Invalid CT Input", ROUND((vt_r / vk_v) * 100, 1)))Long Switchyard Control Cable + Close-In Bus X/R = 18 (Z_b = 0.62 Ohm) Saturation Check
Run 150 m of #12 AWG copper yard leads to the control house (Z_b climbs to B4 = 0.62 Ohm) on a high-X/R bus (B5 = 18): Steady-state Vsym E3 (62.0 V) still looks 5x below 320 V, YET Transient DC-Offset Demand E4 explodes to 1,178.0 V (368.1% of V_k in E5)—proving why utilities specify 1 A secondary CTs (25x lower I^2 * R wire burden) or step up to a 2000:5 C800 ratio.
=IF(ISTEXT(E5), E5, ROUND(((B2 * 1000) / B3) * B4 * (1 + B5), 1))Try the example
Use the original values or change them to test your understanding.