Arte SheetsLearn. Try. Understand.

Process Safety Management, Combustion Engineering & Hazard Analysis

Le Chatelier Mixing Rule: An Illustrative Gas Limit Calculation

Use the approximate Le Chatelier mixing rule for a three-gas teaching example, with its assumptions and limitations clearly stated.

What the mixture rule estimates

The Le Chatelier rule approximates the lower flammability limit (LFL, also called the lower explosive limit or LEL) of a mixture from the composition of its fuel gases and their individual limits in air. This exercise uses methane, propane and hydrogen, with illustrative individual LFLs of 5.0%, 2.1% and 4.0% by volume. Actual limits depend on test conditions, and the rule is an approximation, not a guarantee that a mixture will or will not ignite.

Enter each fuel concentration as a volume percentage of the whole sample, including air. If the complete sample contains 0.60% methane, 0.30% propane and 0.30% hydrogen, their total is 1.20%. Normalising those fuel concentrations gives the fuel composition used in the mixture rule: the estimated mixture LFL is 3.55 vol%, and the sample concentration is 33.79% of that estimated LFL. These are two different quantities, not percentages of the same denominator.

A separate sample with 0.30% methane, 0.105% propane and 0.10% hydrogen has a total fuel concentration of 0.505%, an estimated mixture LFL of 3.74 vol% and a modelled concentration of 13.50% of that LFL.

Teaching calculationFirst sampleSecond sample
Methane / propane / hydrogen in the whole sample (vol%)0.60 / 0.30 / 0.300.30 / 0.105 / 0.10
Total fuel in sample (vol%)1.200.505
Estimated mixture LFL in air (vol%)3.553.74
Sample as a percentage of estimated mixture LFL33.79%13.50%

Formula and input assumptions

For whole-sample fuel concentrations y₁, y₂ and y₃, and corresponding individual LFLs L₁, L₂ and L₃ in the same units, the fuel-normalised mixture estimate is (y₁ + y₂ + y₃) / (y₁/L₁ + y₂/L₂ + y₃/L₃). The estimated sample percentage of the mixture limit is 100 × (y₁/L₁ + y₂/L₂ + y₃/L₃). Enter zero for a gas known to be absent; blank and nonnumeric inputs are rejected. All relevant fuel components must be accounted for; this three-component sheet cannot detect an omitted gas.

This simple model assumes an air-based mixture and uses fixed illustrative component limits. Temperature, pressure, oxygen concentration and inert gases affect flammability; mixtures containing hydrogen can depart from simple mixing-rule predictions. A zero-fuel input has no defined fuel composition, so the worksheet returns a message rather than dividing by zero.

=IF(COUNT(B2:B4)<>3,"Enter numeric component concentrations",IF(OR(B2<0,B3<0,B4<0,SUM(B2:B4)<=0,SUM(B2:B4)>=100),"Check example inputs",SUM(B2:B4)/(B2/5+B3/2.1+B4/4)))

Not a clearance or interlock decision

The result is for learning the arithmetic, not a determination that an atmosphere is safe or compliant and not a setpoint for an interlock. Ventilation, ignition sources, oxygen availability, accumulation and local operating conditions need an assessment by qualified personnel under the applicable requirements and the site’s approved procedures.

Use appropriate, calibrated gas-detection equipment and follow its instructions and site procedures. OSHA notes that combustible-gas instruments have limitations and can give misleading readings in some atmospheres; a spreadsheet is not a substitute for monitoring or an explosion-prevention design.

Try the example

Use the original values or change them to test your understanding.

Further reading