Healthcare & Clinical
Ottawa Knee Rule: Counting Five Pre-Assessed Findings
Explore the five Ottawa knee rule findings using validated illustrative inputs, and understand why a spreadsheet cannot decide whether a patient needs imaging.
A clinical aid for acute knee injuries
The Ottawa knee rule was derived in 1995 and prospectively validated in 1996 to help clinicians consider radiography after acute knee injury. The five findings include age 55 or older, isolated patellar tenderness, fibular head tenderness, inability to flex to 90 degrees, and inability to take four weight-bearing steps at the time of injury and at assessment. The patellar finding is isolated when no other knee bone is tender.
The rule’s performance depends on proper assessment and the patient population. The original adult study excluded some presentations; a separate multicenter study examined children. A negative set of findings does not guarantee there is no fracture or other significant injury, and the sheet cannot assess the mechanism, other injuries, examination reliability or applicability of a local guideline.
A clinician must evaluate acute trauma and determine the need for imaging and follow-up. Do not use a worksheet to clear an injury or force a painful movement.
Count supplied findings for a hypothetical adult
Enter age in completed years in B2. Enter 0 or 1 for each pre-assessed finding in B3:B6; B5 means inability to flex to 90 degrees and B6 means inability to bear weight for four steps both immediately after injury and at assessment. Limping does not by itself mean the person cannot take the required steps. All five inputs must be present; the example cannot determine whether the rule applies.
=IF(COUNT(B2:B6)<>5,"Invalid or missing inputs",IF(OR(B2<18,B2<>INT(B2),AND(B3<>0,B3<>1),AND(B4<>0,B4<>1),AND(B5<>0,B5<>1),AND(B6<>0,B6<>1)),"Invalid or missing inputs",IF(B2>=55,1,0)+SUM(B3:B6)))Describe the entered criteria
This label reflects only the entered numbers. It is not a diagnosis, a recommendation to obtain or skip radiographs, or an injury-clearance decision.
=IF(E2="Invalid or missing inputs","Invalid or missing inputs",IF(E2=0,"No criteria reported present","One or more criteria reported present"))Try the example
Use the original values or change them to test your understanding.