Healthcare & Clinical
San Francisco Syncope Rule: CHESS Factors and Limitations
Count the five published CHESS factors with fictional inputs and understand why a negative rule is not a guarantee of safety.
The five factors in context
Quinn and colleagues derived the San Francisco Syncope Rule from emergency-department patients with syncope or near syncope. Its five factors are history of congestive heart failure, hematocrit below 30%, an abnormal ECG or rhythm as defined in the study, shortness of breath, and triage systolic blood pressure below 90 mmHg. The original derivation examined serious outcomes within seven days.
A later systematic review found that sensitivity and specificity varied across studies. Absence of the five factors does not guarantee a low personal risk, identify the cause of fainting, or establish that discharge is safe. Any clinical decision requires appropriate assessment and the full circumstances.
Count fictional recorded factors
Use B2, B4 and B5 for previously assessed 0-or-1 flags, B3 for hematocrit as a percentage and B6 for systolic pressure in mmHg. This example checks that all inputs are present, the three flags are binary, hematocrit is greater than 0 and at most 100, and blood pressure is positive. These are basic numeric checks, not validation of a patient assessment.
The comparisons are strictly below 30% and below 90 mmHg; equality alone does not trigger either comparison. The output is a number of recorded factors, not a disposition or diagnosis.
=IF(COUNT(B2:B6)<>5,"Enter all five valid numeric inputs and use 0 or 1 for flags",IF(OR(AND(B2<>0,B2<>1),B3<=0,B3>100,AND(B4<>0,B4<>1),AND(B5<>0,B5<>1),B6<=0),"Enter all five valid numeric inputs and use 0 or 1 for flags",(IF(B2=1,1,0)+IF(B3<30,1,0)+IF(B4=1,1,0)+IF(B5=1,1,0)+IF(B6<90,1,0))))Worked example
For fictional values CHF flag 0, hematocrit 27%, ECG flag 0, breathlessness flag 0 and systolic pressure 84 mmHg, the count is 2. This does not determine the cause or treatment.
Try the example
Use the original values or change them to test your understanding.