Attached-Growth Biological Wastewater Treatment, NRC (1946) Trickling-Filter BOD Formula
Trickling Filter NRC Recirculation & BOD5 Removal Formula
Calculate Daily Settled BOD5 Organic Load (kg/d), NRC Effective Biofilm Pass Factor F, Single-Stage + Clarifier BOD5 Removal Efficiency (%), and Final Effluent BOD5 (mg/L).
Cranking trickling-filter recirculation R past 8.0 does NOT climb endlessly—NRC’s (1 + 0.1·R)^2 treatability decay peaks F at R = 8 and shuts off wetting benefits if recycle pumps trip
Attached-Growth Rock and Slag Trickling Filters (Media Volume V m³ fed Primary-Clarified Wastewater Q m³/d at Settled BOD_5 C_0 mg/L -> **Daily Organic Load W = (Q * C_0) / 1,000** kg BOD_5/d) recycle Q_r = R * Q (Recirculation Ratio R = Q_r / Q) to keep rotary distributor arms flushing sloughed zoogloeal biofilm and dilute incoming strength. Analyzing 34 full-scale wastewater plants, the U.S. National Research Council (NRC, 1946) derived **Effective Biofilm Pass Factor F = (1 + R) / ((1 + 0.1 * R)^2) (accounting for diminishing 10% substrate treatability per pass) and the SI-Converted First-Stage + Secondary-Clarifier Efficiency E = 100 / (1 + 0.4432 * sqrt(W / (V * F))) (%, where 0.4432 converts imperial 0.0085 lb/(ac·ft) to kg/(m³·d)), fixing Clarified Effluent C_e = C_0 * (1 - E / 100)** (mg/L).
Verify on a Municipal Single-Stage Rock Trickling Filter—Influent_Flow Q = 4,800 m³/d (B2), Primary-Settled_BOD_5 C_0 = 175 mg/L (B3), Media_Volume V = 1,650 m³ (B4), and Recirculation_Ratio R = 1.50 (B5): Daily Organic Load W equals 840.0 kg BOD_5/d (E2), NRC Effective Pass Factor F equals 1.890 (E3), Overall BOD_5 Removal Efficiency reaches 81.30% (E4), and Secondary-Clarifier Effluent BOD_5 equals 32.7 mg/L (E5).
| NRC (1946) Trickling-Filter KPI (Media Volume V=1,650 m³) | Formula | Verified Output |
|---|---|---|
| Daily Organic Load W (kg BOD5/d) | (Influent_Q_m3_d * Settled_BOD_mg_L) / 1000 | 840.0 kg/d (2,444.0 kg/d cannery surge) |
| NRC Effective Pass Factor F | (1 + R) / ((1 + 0.1 * R) ^ 2) | 1.890 @ R=1.5 (1.000 @ recycle pump off) |
| First-Stage BOD5 Removal E (%) | 100 / (1 + 0.4432 * SQRT(W / (V * F))) | 81.30% (64.96% overloaded) |
| Clarified Effluent BOD5 (mg/L) | Settled_BOD_mg_L * (1 - Removal_Pct / 100) | 32.7 mg/L (91.1 mg/L permit violation) |
NRC (1946) SI Trickling-Filter Organic Loading & Effective Pass Formula
Validate Flow_Rate Q in [50, 250,000] m³/d, Settled_BOD5 C_0 in [30, 1,500] mg/L, Media_Volume V in [20, 50,000] m³, and Recirculation_Ratio R in [0, 8.0].
=LET(qf_d, B2, cz_m, B3, vm_c, B4, rr_x, B5, wb_k, (qf_d * cz_m) / 1000, fp_x, (1 + rr_x) / ((1 + 0.1 * rr_x) ^ 2), ef_p, 100 / (1 + 0.4432 * SQRT(wb_k / (vm_c * fp_x))), IF(OR(qf_d < 50, qf_d > 250000, cz_m < 30, cz_m > 1500, vm_c < 20, vm_c > 50000, rr_x < 0, rr_x > 8), "Invalid NRC Input", ROUND(cz_m * (1 - ef_p / 100), 1)))Seasonal Food-Processing Load (Q = 9,400 m³/d, C_0 = 260 mg/L) + Recycle Off (R = 0) Check
Take a seasonal fruit-cannery surge (B2 = 9,400 m³/d at B3 = 260 mg/L -> 2,444.0 kg/d in E2) while turning off recirculation (B5 = 0 -> F = 1.000 in E3): NRC Removal E4 sags to 64.96%, pushing Effluent BOD_5 E5 nearly 3x higher to 91.1 mg/L alongside Psychoda filter-fly breeding on dry stones.
=IF(ISTEXT(E5), E5, LET(wb_k, (B2 * B3) / 1000, fp_x, (1 + B5) / ((1 + 0.1 * B5) ^ 2), ROUND(100 / (1 + 0.4432 * SQRT(wb_k / (B4 * fp_x))), 2)))Try the example
Use the original values or change them to test your understanding.